Largo Gemelli 1, 20123 Milano
Ph. +39 02 7234 3715/3716
Fax +39 02 7234 3721
Ernesto Ugo Savona
Caneppele Stefano, Ernesto Ugo Savona, Alberto Aziani, Crime proofing of the New Tobacco Products Directive, Trento: Transcrime – Università degli Studi di Trento, September 2013 © 2013 Transcrime – Joint Research Centre on Transnational Crime
This study concerns the crime proofing of the Proposal for the Revision of the Tobacco Products Directive presented in December 2012, and it is an update of a study on the crime proofing of the policy options under consideration of the revision of Directive 2001/37/EC.
The crime proofing of legislation is a scientific approach developed by Transcrime in 2006 (Savona, 2006a; Savona, 2006b; Savona, Calderoni et al., 2006; Savona, Maggioni, et al., 2006; Morgan and Clarke, 2006; Albrecht and Kilchling, 2002). The core idea is that legislation may produce unintended opportunities for crime, thereby having potential criminogenic effects. When these opportunities and where they may occur is known, the legislation may be “proofed” against crime.
This study is concerned with the impact of the new Tobacco Products Directive (TPD) on crime, and all the more so on the Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products (henceforth ITTP), an area that has not been considered by any of the impact assessment studies carried out by the EU Commission in preparation of the new Directive. Consequently, no knowledge is officially available on the impact of the new regulation upon the ITTP. This report aims at filling this gap by using the available data and making estimates.
In January 2012, Transcrime presented a study which proofed the policy options under consideration for the revision of EU Directive 2001/37/EC against the risks of unintended criminal opportunities for the illicit trade in tobacco products (Calderoni, Savona, & Solmi, 2012).
The study highlighted that “DG SANCO paid almost no attention to the impact on the ITTP” and that “certain measures considered for the revision of the TPD may have serious consequences” regarding possible risks of increased ITTP (Calderoni et al. 2012, p.42).
The impact assessment (IA) released on December 2012 denies the risks of the ITTP. The EU Commission declared “that the preferred policy options do not – in the assessment of the Commission – lead to increased illicit trade” (European Commission, 2012a, p. 6).
More than being the result of an IA of the policy options and their trade-off on ITTP, this statement is an a priori assumption that excludes the area of crime from the IA carried out by the EU Commission. This is a serious flaw that may compromise the validity of the results of the impact assessment itself, and which does not comply with the EU’s official impact assessment guidelines (European Commission, 2009).
(Webinar) RICICLAGGIO E INFILTRAZIONI DELLA CRIMINALITÀ ORGANIZZATA: RIPARTIRE CON NUOVI INDICATORI DI RISCHIO – Michele Riccardi together with other experts talks about the new risk scenarios generated by COVID19.
DATACROS MID-TERM MEETING – Michele Riccardi and Antonio Bosisio discuss with partners the first results of DATACROS project.
DATA SCIENCE FOR POLICING, SECURITY AND PUBLIC SAFETY – Marco Dugato discusses the main existing approaches to crime forecasting at Cardiff University.
THE NEED FOR AN EU PLAN TO END THE VICIOUS CYCLE OF GRAND CORRUPTION – Prof. Ernesto Savona discusses about the EU needs to rethink its overall approach to asset recovery at the event organized by Transparency International EU.
EUROPEAN CRIME PREVENTION CONFERENCE (EUCPN) – Prof. Francesco Calderoni presents the final results of European project Proton.
TRAIN THE TRAINERS – Thomas Joyce talks about the value of radicalisation monitoring and the use of possible indicators allowing an early detection of radicalization phenomenon at the Department of Penitentiary Administration.
COOPERATION BETWEEN EUROPOL, ACADEMIA AND RESEARCH EXPERTS – Prof. Savona participates in the roundtable ‘Cooperation between Europol, Academia and Research Experts’.
TRAin TRAINING FINAL CONFERENCE – Prof. Savona discusses the European future of tools for monitoring radicalization processes in prison.
EMPIRICAL AML RESEARCH CONFERENCE – Michele Riccardi discusses how to assess the risk of illicit financial flows through the analysis of cross border ownership links of European businesses.
EUCPN Board Meeting – Prof. Francesco Calderoni presents the final results of European project Proton.
🗓️#SaveTheDate Mancano pochissimi giorni all’apertura delle iscrizioni ai colloqui di selezione per la #LaureaMagistrale in #PolitichePerLaSicurezza @Unicatt. Non dimenticare di prenotare il tuo! Iscrizioni 👉 https://t.co/2eXNhz7Ysc Info 👉 https://t.co/qrnsVxYbTz #PoliSi2020 https://t.co/wH1TSPmnXx
On @CORDIS_EU website you can find the Results in Brief article on our #ProtonEu #H2020 project aimed at improving existing knowledge on the processes of #recruitment to #OrganisedCrime and #terrorist networks @Unicatt #AgentBasedModels #crimeprevention 👉https://t.co/H6BaShJaWx https://t.co/fz7hP50gN3
Su @RaiUno il Prof. @ernestosavona ha sottolineato la necessità di un processo di semplificazione normativa che combini regole efficaci con garanzie che riducano il rischio di #infiltrazioni criminali #burocrazia #CodiceDegliAppalti #ripartenza @Unicatt 👇https://t.co/9Xfl8ZPUT7